Welcome to Old World Pizza
Old World Pizza, located in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, offers a delightful journey into authentic Italian flavors. Known for its fresh, homemade ingredients, this charming eatery features a brick pizza oven that creates perfectly baked pies. Customers rave about the signature red sauce, indulgent meatballs, and standout dishes like the Ultimate Margarita and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizzas. Beyond the food, the welcoming atmosphere and attentive service make diners feel like family. With a commitment to quality and community, Old World Pizza is not just a meal; it’s an experience that leaves patrons eagerly anticipating their next visit.
-
732 W New Orleans St Suite 120, Broken Arrow, OK 74011, United States Hotline: +1 539-367-2563
Welcome to the heart of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, where flavor meets tradition at Old World Pizza. Nestled at 732 W New Orleans St Suite 120, this restaurant has quickly become a local favorite, and for good reason. With a commitment to quality, Old World Pizza offers a culinary experience that marries classic Italian recipes with fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
The moment you step into Old World Pizza, you are greeted not just by the tantalizing aromas wafting from their authentic brick pizza oven, but also by a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like home. Customer reviews consistently highlight the exceptional service, with many noting how the staff treats patrons like family. It's this personal touch that sets Old World apart from other dining options.
At Old World Pizza, each dish tells a story. From their renowned homemade meatballs to the drool-worthy ultimate margarita pizza, every item on the menu reflects a dedication to quality and flavor. Customers rave about the red sauce—described as "to die for"—which is crafted in-house, ensuring a freshness that can't be beaten. For those looking to explore beyond pizza, the pasta stands out as another must-try. Made with love and fresh ingredients, it leaves diners eager for the next visit.
If you're in the mood for something unique, the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza comes highly recommended, alongside addictively delicious garlic knots that keep guests coming back for more. Desserts are not to be overlooked either; the cannoli and chocolate gelato have garnered acclaim, tempting even the most disciplined diners. One visitor expressed regret for not discovering this gem sooner, a sentiment echoed by many who have tasted the magic of Old World Pizza.
Moreover, Old World Pizza doesn't just serve food; they invest in the community. They've been known to sponsor local sports teams, demonstrating their commitment to giving back, and winning the hearts of Broken Arrow residents even further.
Whether you're a pizza aficionado or a casual diner, Old World Pizza is a destination worth exploring. With a menu that inspires culinary adventure and an atmosphere that feels like family, your taste buds will thank you. So gather your friends, bring an appetite, and prepare for a delightful meal. Old World Pizza is ready to impress you with every bite!
For inquiries or to place an order, you can reach them at +1 539-367-2563. Don't wait too long to make your visit!
I have been here several times and I have tried several different items from the menu. There has not been a single thing that I didn’t LOVE. It’s always fresh and delicious. The red sauce is to die for and so are the homemade meatballs and the ultimate margarita pizza. I have had NYC pizza and it doesn’t even compare to how good Old World is. Customer service has always been great here and when I have been on really busy nights they are always up front and honest if it is going to take longer than normal. Also, I have seen that they have sponsored local Broken Arrow sports teams and I think it’s just amazing to see local businesses giving back to the community that supports them.
Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza was really good and the garlic knots are addicting. This is coming from a guy that is not normally a big fan of pizza. Oh and our waitress was very attentive, I think her name was Gigi.
UPDATE. Again, Standing ovation to this pizza place!. Thank you Lyly and team. The nice and humble way you treat customers talks volume of what is in your hearts. You always make us feel like family. Now, what about the food?. As pizza freaks ourselves this place is great. Beside the pizzas the pasta is way too good. Fresh ingredients!. How come we didn't knew about this restaurant before?. Fresh ingredients. Dough and sauce done in house. Brick pizza oven. Cannoli and their chocolate gelato are a most. Service is A. Make you feel good. If you live in Broken Arrow, Tulsa or just passing by this place is worth giving a try.
First time trying pizza from OWP, and I was impressed! Plenty of toppings, good size, and decent cost for what you get. The taste was great! I’ll be back! Yes, I did eat half of the pizza. :)
We were so excited to find out Old World Pizza opened back up! The pizzas never disappoint and are always so fresh. Missed seeing the staff and was so happy to be greeted by everyone when walking in. The new store front looks amazing and we are so happy the crew is back!
One of the best pizza places in our area!!! Great Caesar Salad, Great Pizza!! A must Try anyone who likes pizza! I will be back to try everything else on the menu.
I absolutely love this place! I have never been disappointed. Their homemade ranch is amazing and doesn’t have that vinegar taste! I love their pepperoni pizza and a 10” is a good size if you are wanting to have a personal pizza and possible leftovers. I have never had bad service nor have I ever had bad food here. Highly recommend if you are in the mood for some local pizza!
We absolutely love this place, my only regret is that we didn’t find it sooner. I have tried every pizza restaurant in Tulsa and the quality here sets the bar. My advice to anyone dining here is to explore the menu, try new things. The desserts are fantastic, the vodka sauce is some of the best I’ve had, and the pizza is obviously 10/10. We enjoy talking to the owner, she is such a kind person!